Antonio's New York Style Pizza

Enjoy authentic New York Style Pizza at Antonio's in St. Augustine. Savor crispy crust, flavorful calzones, meatball subs, white pizza, garlic knots, baklava, and more. Takeout only. Call +1 904-794-0117!

Welcome to Antonio's New York Style Pizza

Experience the finest dining

Antonio's New York Style Pizza
Antonio's New York Style Pizza
Antonio's New York Style Pizza
Antonio's New York Style Pizza

Discover the taste of New York right in St. Augustine at Antonio's New York Style Pizza. This charming restaurant, located at 934 Santa Maria Blvd, serves up traditional New York-style pizza that captures the essence of the Big Apple. Whether you are craving a classic pepperoni slice or a creamy white pizza, you will find the perfect pie here. Fans rave about its crispy crust and generous toppings, making each bite a satisfying experience.

The menu is not just limited to pizza; indulge in calzones, hearty meatball subs, and delectable baklava. Antonio’s invites everyone, from families to pizza enthusiasts, to enjoy a comforting meal in a cozy atmosphere.

Antonio's New York Style Pizza stands out for its extensive menu and vibrant atmosphere. With only take-out options, it ensures that quick meals are both delicious and convenient. Some highlights includes the Small Pepperoni Pizza, which is popular among regulars. The garlic knots deliver a mouthwatering appetizer, offering a burst of flavor. Seating options include outdoor dining, where patrons can enjoy their meal under the sun or stars, a refreshing change from typical dining experiences.

Did someone say ‘perfect summer night’? The restaurant processes large numbers of orders, especially on busy nights, making it a go-to spot for local pizza lovers.

Families often find themselves squeezed into the usually buzzing environment, creating a lively and inviting community feel. When it comes to drinks, a range of 2-liter beverages complements any meal, priced affordably at just $5.00. Antonio's consistently delivers comfort food that appeals to both old-timers and newcomers to St. Augustine, making every visit memorable.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

934 Santa Maria Blvd, St. Augustine, FL 32086, United States

Phone

+1 904-794-0117

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Antonio's New York Style Pizza
Antonio's New York Style Pizza
Antonio's New York Style Pizza
Antonio's New York Style Pizza

Antonio's New York Style Pizza does more than serve slices; it curates a taste of New York in every dish. The culinary journey begins when you step into this welcoming restaurant, adorned with nostalgic decor that evokes memories of bustling New York streets. The menu, featuring 49 various items, showcases an impressive range of options. From specialty pizzas and subs to desserts like baklava and tiramisu, there's something for everyone.

The most sought-after dishes include the Meat Lovers specialty pizza and succulent meatball parmesan sub. With an overall price averaging $13.55, this restaurant provides hearty meals without breaking the bank.

Beyond traditional dishes, Antonio's takes pride in using quality ingredients to ensure each bite bursts with flavor. Diners rave about the crispy and chewy texture of their pizza crust, carefully crafted to perfection.

The reputation for quality is a badge of honor in the local community. The dining experience thrives on vibrant discussions, laughter, and the warmth that customers share. Everyone feels welcomed, and the staff greets you like family. Peak hours show the restaurant bustling with life—especially on Tuesdays at lunch. Pro-tip: to avoid long waits, try visiting on a Monday evening.

As a cornerstone of community spirit, Antonio's often hosts events or special deals that resonate with locals. The combination of a dedicated team, a thoughtfully designed menu, and a commitment to traditional flavors creates a spot where cherished memories are made. Whether it's a quick take-out order or a family gathering, this restaurant guarantees a satisfying dining experience.

Antonio's New York Style Pizza

The exterior of Antonio's New York Style Pizza invites curiosity, with its colorful signage and bustling outdoor seating area. The ambiance captures a relaxed vibe, perfect for enjoying a slice while soaking in St. Augustine’s charm. Trees surrounding the patio create a shady retreat within the vibrant atmosphere. This spot tends to draw patrons, especially during weekends when the city comes alive. The layout accommodates both quick takes and leisurely meals, all while feeling like an extension of the lively streets of New York.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday5-8:30 PM
  • Monday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-8:30 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Great food and service. We shared the pepperoni and sausage Stromboli. Portions were huge. The garlic bits were top notch.

C
Chris S.

Great pizza and garlic knots! My take-out order was ready within 15 minutes. I got an XL to feed myself for a few days while my wife is out of town and I might have overestimated my appetite.

W
Will M.

We had a mixup and thought we were ordering from a different place next door to us so we had to find and drive a bit far to retrieve our pizza. Well sometimes the universe knows better and we had an amazing deluxe pizza. It was gone before I could get a picture

I
Island I.

This could be the most affordable Lunch special in St. Augustine. Very very good slices. I am originally from NJ. Approved slices...solid. 2 slices and a drink...

S
Steve

First time going in yesterday. I was starving and it was on my way to work. I was served quickly with delicious food. I had the eggplants and the Greek salad. Very large portions, excellently cooked eggplant and a very flavorful salad. Thank you so much and I will be back!

C
C L.

Great neighborhood pizza place. Lunch special 2 slices and drink. $8

T
Tim T.